The Politics Of Irish Stamps.

The Decade of Centenaries.

The odd thing about Stamp Collecting (besides the eccentricity of people who collect stamps) is that it can be extremely “political”. In the case of Ireland this is hardly surprising.

An Irish Stamp Album is in fact, “Ireland’s Greatest Hits” Album. The History, Culture, Spirituality, Music, Fauna, Flora, Sport etc are all there. And yes…Politics. By any standards, the decision not to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the Death of Michael Collins was an act of Fianna Fáil spite.

But the Politics is largely outside the Stamp Album.

The postal authority “An Post” has a committee which decides the new stamp issues. Most recently, people have been invited to submit ideas for 2016 and in a few months, we will be asked to submit ideas for 2017. And so on.

But the Politics of Stamp Collecting is not just about the historic events depicted. It is also about the manner in which these events are depicted. It is a form of “revisionism”.

Two examples. The 150th Anniversary of the 1798 Rebellion was marked by the issue of two, rather drab stamps, featuring Wolfe Tone. But in 1998, the Bicentenary issue of five different stamps featured  French involvement, Henry Joy McCracken and curiously but properly generic “Women of 1798”. And the 1803 Rebellion aniversary in 1953 was marked by a two stamp issue fea)turing Robert Emmet. But in 2003, the three stamp issue featured Emmett, Thomas Russell and (again properly) Anne Devlin.

The 1916 Rising is regularly represented on Irish stamps. In 1941 (25 years) there were shortages of paper and ink (World War Two was ongoing) which produced a two-stamp issue of a very temporary nature, followed later in the year by a single stamp.

In 1966 (50 years) a set of eight stamps was issued. There was a generic stamp and a stamp for each of the seven signatories of the Proclamation. Of course, I was 13 years old and I remember 1966, all too well. The extent to which the 1966 Events contributed to the Norn Iron “Troubles” which started in 1969 is a matter of debate but what is certain is that three Catholic deaths at the hands of a revived Ulster Volunteer Force can be partly attributed to Easter Commemoration and of course unionist sectarian hatred.

But we can also say that the outbreak of the Troubles created something of a dilemna in Dublin. Successive Irish governments from 1969 faced the problem of denouncing northern nationalist “terrorism” and facing the reality that the Irish State was established by a previous generation of “terrorists”. Thus in 1991 (75 years) and 2006 (90 years), the single stamps issued were muted and almost apologetic.

Which brings us to the “Decade of Centenaries” . The period 1912-1922 was a traumatic period in Irish History…Home Rule Act, the formation of unionist and nationalist militias, the Ulster Covenant, The General Lock Out, World War One, The Easter Rising, The Somme, The War of Independence, anti-Catholic pograms in the North, The Treaty, The Civil War.

I have not been a fan of Conflict Resolution. But the Decade of Centenaries while very real, also has a degree of “manufacture” and “manipulation”. There is of course a need for historians to look at the History of the 1912-1922 period and certainly a need to de-construct myths. But the creation of new myths such as “shared history” with a view to creating a Post-Conflict world is not something historians should do.

Oddly…the treatment of History motivates me more than Politics. Why is that? Well, on retirement, I went back to Queens University to study a History degree. I graduated at 57 years of age and I tend to believe the words I heard in the Whitla Hall on Graduation Day. I have the skills to understand History. I dont like to see it as a tool of Politcians, especially LetsGetAlongerists.

So….Stamp Collecting and the Decade of Centenaries.

An Post has already issued stamps to commemorate the founding of the Irish Volunteers, the Irish Citizen Army (and copies of the withdrawn stamp now fetch prices in excess of €500) and Cumann na mBan. The General Lock Out has been recognised and Edward Carson and John Redmond appear on the Home Rule Act Centenary stamp. And two stamps, featuring “recruiting posters” have commemorated the outbreak of the First World War.

But 2015 is only a few weeks away and I have been sent details of the Stamp Programme for 2015. There will be three issues than cover the Decade of Centenaries theme…..the funeral of O’Donovan Rossa (Pearse’s oration), the Galipoli Landings and the sinking of the Lusitania. Has there ever been a greater example of…..”balance”?

The O’Rossa Funeral is for the Republicans. The Galipoli Landings is for the old “Ireland was/is British too” devotees and the sinking of the Lusitania off the southern coast of Ireland is one for civilians and pacifists.

But is there a LetsGetAlongerist dimension? Curiously yes. Incredibly…in my view….the 50th Anniversary of the Meeting of Seán Lemass and Terence O’Neill will be recognised in January. You couldnt make it up. I still have one of the snowballs that Rev Ian Paisley threw that day.

 

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to The Politics Of Irish Stamps.

  1. Welcome back, FJH! I’m not much of a stamp fan but I’m told that my late father possessed a commemorative collection of all the 1966 stamps which one of his brothers later purloined. We are somewhat estranged from that side of the family so I’ve never been able to follow up on it. It would be wonderful to have it even though I’m more of a bibliophile. First editions by Pearse, etc. are now selling for crazy money. I have a memoir by his sister, bought it for 150 euros, was recently offered 500. No chance! 😉

    By the by, putting Carson on an Irish stamp is like putting Mussolini on an Italian one. There is a line that should not be crossed.

  2. I have the 1966 Stamps. I actually bought them in Monaghan on the Saturday of the World Cup Final. The 1966 Stamps are a bit of a watersvhed as Ireland had a very conservative policy about issuing stamps…and eight stamps was a big thing. Certainly around 1999 and 2000 Ireland issued 36 stamps in stages plus 15 GAA Fotball and 15 Hurling Stamps….it was then that An Post killed off the Golden Goose…it was the last straw for many of us.
    Sometime before Easter 2016, I must get a First Day Cover of the 1916 Stamps. A FDC is effectively a souvenir rather than something genuinely posted as “mail” but it would look good framed.
    Ebay makes prices variable. But anything around £25 to £35 would be ok.
    The Irish Citizen Army stamp was issued in January but was withdrawn at 9.10am on the day of issue. It featured a portrait of Captain Jack White, the main organiser of the ICA. A historian at NUIG claimed it was not Jack.
    It was re-issued in April without Jack.
    As a consequence, few were sold. One sold on Ebay last month…€676 and the going rate at Ian Whytes Auctions during summer was about €400 plus.
    The real irony is that Jack White is a forgotten man.
    Northern unionist stock…Boer War Officer ….who turned socialist and nationalist, even anarchist. So …his stamp is now the most valuable Irish Commemorative.
    Funny Old World.

  3. benmadigan says:

    I go in for books rather than stamps and i’ve got a little booklet about jack White (very dapper looking in his photo) first commander irish citizen army. It was written by andrew boyd from belfast. Whyte was on the continent during the easter rising but was later arrested in wales as he tried to rouse the miners to protest against the shooting of james Connolly

    • I wonder if this is the same photograph that was used on the stamp.
      Dr Leo Keohane NUIG saw the pre-issue bulletin from An Post and claims kt is not Jack White. In the corcumstances, An Post !(9.10 am on morning of issue had no option but to withdraw it.
      It had pnly been on sale for ten minutes (forty in GPO Dublin).
      At lunchtime in two County Louth post offices, I tried to buy it…and actually saw an unopened pack in the second office.
      It was a coincidence that I had tried to buy some …I blogged about it at the time. The first Post Office gave me no information but the second one was very informative.
      I have seen the information booklet. And it saw no problem. Certainly it was like a photograph I had previously seen which was supposed to be “Captain Jack”.
      I have been trying for nearly a byear to work out where I would have seen a photograph and now you have made me think it must have been the Andrew Boyd book.
      This might mean that An Post used the same photograph as Boyd.
      When I get home (about 20 minutes), I should be able to post a pic of the “withdrawn” stamp on ebay..

      White is a very interesting character. Died in Belfast and had a reconciliation with some members of his family.
      Does the Boyd book give any indication where he is buried.
      Please look out for a follow up post from me.

  4. benmadigan says:

    have also posted this on your follow-up post

    On the cover of Andrew boyd’s booklet Jack white is wearing a hat, jacket, shirt and tie – no uniform.
    Will try and scan in a picture later this week when I can access some computer help .

    I can find no attribution for the photo in the booklet but have no reason to doubt its veracity as Boyd was very careful about his sources when writing

    According to Boyd, White “died in a belfast nursing home in February 1946 and he is buried in the graveyard at Broughshane First Presbyterian Church”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s